I finally saw Observe and Report after hearing and reading so much about it. It was a hateful, disgusting, and totally depressing little comedy. I loved it! I love dark comedies, and it's rare that I see comedies that are this dark, so whenever I hear somebody mention that a particular film is a dark comedy I go running toward it. What can i say? I just like them. I have a memory of being shushed for laughing too hard in an audience full of horrified onlookers during Todd Solondz's Happiness that I will always cherish.
There was one scene in particular I was a little worried about. Some of the feminist blogs I read regularly were livid over a scene in which Ronnie (played by Seth Rogan) is fucking Brandi (God I love that name- played by brilliantly by Anna Faris) who is passed out drunk and high in a pool of her own vomit. Ronnie stops in the middle of the act to ask if she's okay and she wakes up long enough to shout, "Why'd you stop mother fucker?"
It's a totally offensive scene, to be sure, but the whole movie is hateful and offensive. And I'm not sure if it's more or less offensive in a movie that has already spent so much time setting up what an awful person Brandi is. The film seems to have a strange relationship to its female characters. All the women in the film are terrible people and not just because they're being stalked by a flasher in the mall parking lot who shouts "Touch it, slut!" and "See my dick!" at them. No, it's more that they're manipulative and wholly self-serving.
It's not like the men are spared. Every single character, including the hero, are pretty much the most pathetic, self-involved monsters you could ever imagine. The movie almost seems to be daring you to hate it. I guess that's probably why i loved it. Like John Waters' films from the 1970's, it asks you to delight in awful behavior. (It's been way too long since I've seen Female Trouble, by the way.) It's just that Brandi is especially nasty and self-serving. So why was she my favorite character?
This probably isn't very politically correct, but I wonder: do gay men hate women? Look at the women who are gay icons. They are universally over-the-top and often unkind or laughably vain. Sometimes even alcoholics or drug addicts. I wonder why that is. Do gay men idolize a strong woman and a dramatic story, or do we like laughing at train wrecks? Or is it both? The female characters in my play are often very tough and out spoken and crude while men tend to be more meek and thoughtful. Some of this is my background, as I come from a huge family of tough broads and quiet men, but that doesn't explain why I love Amy Winehouse so damn much.
In the end it seemed like the movie kind of hated Brandi, but her nasty behavior had the opposite effect on me. I rooted for her. But does my rooting for her condone movies in which women are betrayed as shallow and cruel?
I was thinking about all of this when I went to IMDB to read up on the movie. Slightly off the subject, but I don't think anybody hates women as much as this lovely IMDB commenter, who wrote the following of the controversial scene:
First I'm a PSY major so I know what I'm talking about...
Face it, girls like the Brandi character are a dime a dozen, slutty
parasites like that are everywhere, and they deserve to get used for
sex, most especially if they get overly drunk to the point of passing
out. Let's face it, girls like that/her are no mother Teressa...Brandi
was only out with the dude for free food and free booze!!! Girls like
that, take and take and take...with zero consideration, they're used to
having orbiters around them at their beck and call, and used to skimmin
drinks and other things from guys, with zero in return...so yeah, they
deserve whatever cummms to them. Besides, chicks like that tend to be
pretty screwed up anyways...probably mollested as a kid, or
whatever...lots of issues, and probably addicted to semen too!
Seriously, a lot of girls are addicted to semen, it's in psychology today! Check it out.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200210/crying-over-spilled-semen
SOOOO YEAH, GO RONNNNNNIIIIEEEE!!!!
Wow. Just... wow. Guess I'm off the hook.
Chin up, ladies... this dude will be your shrink some day! Just don't drink any of his jizz. You could become addicted!
Just for fun, the classic Christmas Tree scene from Female Trouble.